Email Marketing vs Social Media: Which Channel Wins in 2025?

Email marketing vs social media—it's not really a competition. Both have their place. But if you're deciding where to invest limited time and budget, the data points clearly in one direction.

This guide compares the two channels on what actually matters: reach, engagement, conversion, and ROI.

The Numbers at a Glance

Metric	Email Marketing	Social Media
Average ROI	$36-42 per $1	$2.80 per $1
Reach	99% check daily	Algorithm-dependent
Conversion rate	6-8%	1-3%
Organic reach	100% of list	2-6% of followers
Ownership	You own the list	Platform owns audience

Email Marketing Advantages

1. You Own the List

Your email list is yours. No algorithm changes, no policy updates, no platform shutdown can take it away.

Social media followers? You're renting access from the platform. When algorithms change (they always do), your reach drops.

Real example: Organic Facebook reach has dropped from ~16% to ~2% since 2012. Those followers still exist—you just can't reach them.

2. Higher Conversion Rates

Email converts 3-5x better than social media for most businesses.

Why:

• People check email with intent
• Less distraction and competition
• More space to communicate value
• Direct, personal channel

3. Better Targeting

With email, you can segment based on:

• Purchase history
• Engagement behavior
• Demographics
• Custom attributes
• Website activity

Social media targeting is limited and getting more restricted due to privacy regulations.

4. Direct, Personal Channel

Email lands in someone's personal inbox. It feels like a 1:1 communication.

Social media is public, noisy, and impersonal by comparison.

5. Higher ROI

$36-42 return for every $1 spent on email vs. ~$2.80 for social media.

Email wins on pure economics—and it's not close.

Social Media Advantages

1. Discovery and Awareness

Social media excels at reaching new audiences:

• Viral potential
• Shareable content
• Hashtag discovery
• Algorithm-powered distribution

Email requires you already have the address. Social can find new people.

2. Engagement and Community

Social media enables:

• Two-way conversations
• Community building
• User-generated content
• Real-time interaction

3. Brand Personality

Platforms like Twitter/X, Instagram, and TikTok let you show personality in ways email can't easily match.

4. Visual Storytelling

Instagram, TikTok, YouTube are built for visual content that can be harder to deliver via email.

5. Younger Demographics

Some younger audiences prefer social media communication—though email usage remains high across all ages (99% check daily).

When to Use Each Channel

Use Email For:

Use Case	Why Email Wins
Converting leads	Higher conversion rates
Nurturing relationships	Personal, direct
Selling products	Clear CTAs, trackable
Customer retention	Post-purchase sequences
Time-sensitive offers	Reaches inbox directly

Use Social Media For:

Use Case	Why Social Wins
Building awareness	Reaching new audiences
Community engagement	Conversations, interaction
Content distribution	Sharing, virality
Brand building	Personality, visual storytelling
Customer service	Public, responsive support

The Best Strategy: Combine Both

The winning approach uses both channels strategically:

Social → Email Pipeline

1. Social media creates awareness
2. Lead magnet captures email addresses
3. Email nurtures and converts

This captures social's discovery benefit while using email's conversion power.

Email → Social Amplification

1. Email delivers valuable content
2. Subscribers share on social
3. New audience sees content
4. New subscribers join email list

Cross-Channel Campaigns

• Announce on social, deliver via email
• Share email content on social
• Use email to drive social engagement
• Retarget email subscribers on social

Measuring Effectiveness

Email Metrics

Metric	Good	Excellent
Open rate	20%+	30%+
Click rate	2%+	4%+
Conversion rate	2%+	5%+
Revenue per email	$0.10+	$0.50+

Social Media Metrics

Metric	Good	Excellent
Engagement rate	1%+	3%+
Click rate	0.5%+	1%+
Conversion rate	1%+	2%+
Follower growth	2%/mo	5%/mo

Resource Allocation

If You're Starting Out

Focus on email first:

• Higher ROI = faster path to revenue
• Build an owned audience
• Add social once email is working

If You Have Both

Typical effective allocation:

• Email: 60-70% of marketing effort
• Social: 30-40% of marketing effort

Adjust based on your audience and business model.

Time Investment

Email (weekly):

• 1-2 emails to list
• Automation monitoring
• List growth tactics

Social (daily):

• Content posting
• Engagement and community
• Trend monitoring

Common Mistakes

Email Mistakes

• Treating it like social (broadcast only, no relationship)
• Not growing the list actively
• Ignoring automation opportunities
• Poor deliverability management

Social Mistakes

• Expecting email-like conversion rates
• Ignoring the algorithm reality
• Not connecting social to email capture
• Overinvesting relative to returns

Strategic Mistakes

• Going all-in on one channel
• Not measuring properly
• Comparing apples to oranges

The Verdict

Email wins for conversion and ROI. It's not close.

Social wins for discovery and awareness. It's how people find you.

The best marketers use social to build audiences and email to convert them. Don't choose—use both strategically.

Ready to maximize your email marketing? Brew helps you create high-converting emails in seconds with AI.

Start email marketing →